Aaron Rodgers’ Mystery Wife Has Potentially Been Identified by Popular Podcasters: ‘We’re Pretty Positive’

It looks like Aaron Rodgers’ mystery wife may not be an AI chatbot, after all.

Madeline Hill and Charlotte Wilder, cohosts of the “Sports Gossip Show,” believe they have identified the woman that the Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback has only identified as Brittani.

“We are pretty sure that we found Brittani and her sisters Kristy and Mia,” Wilder said on the Tuesday, January 20 episode. “This is relevant because one of Aaron Rodgers’ very good friend is a rapper named Mike, and Mike says he’s married to a woman named Kristy, who is sisters with Aaron Rodgers’ wife, and that they have a 20-year-old sister-in-law named Mia.”

Rodgers, 42, first revealed that he was married in a June 2025 press conference after he showed up to Steelers training camp wearing what appeared to be a wedding ring. He explained in a subsequent appearance on ESPN’s The Pat McAfee Show that his wife, who he identified as Brittani (spelled with an I), “doesn’t want to be in the public eye.”

Rodgers first referred to Brittani as his girlfriend during a December 2024 appearance on The Pat McAfee Show, shortly after his split from model Mallory Edens. Before that, he was engaged to actress Shailene Woodley and has had high-profile relationships with professional NASCAR driver Danica Patrick and actress Olivia Munn.

Wilder and Hill did not go into detail about how they came to the conclusion that Brittani is real, amid speculation that she is an AI chatbot, with Hill explaining that they did not want to “dox” someone who wants to stay private.

Wilder, however, speculated that Rodgers may have wanted the media to figure out her identity.

“I will say that it seems to me that Aaron Rodgers would like nothing more than for us to dox his wife and her sisters so that he could say, ‘Look, the media is awful and inappropriate and out to get me,’ even though I would argue he has given the public just enough information to be able to find them,” she said.

She continued, “He’s baiting [the] media. He’s leaving breadcrumbs that are gonna make people curious and then preparing to use that as ammo to get mad at them if they find out where the trail of the breadcrumbs ends up.”

Wilder added that Rodgers was dropping those “breadcrumbs” as far back as last summer, when he would do live appearances with Mike.

“They would talk about their sister-in-law Mia,” she said. “There were leads that made this not impossible, which leads us to think that this is Aaron Rodgers being a contrarian enigma yet again, but not terribly convincingly. We think he’s just waiting for someone to put the pieces together so he can get mad at them. So we’re not gonna give him the satisfaction of telling you what the pieces are except that we’re pretty sure she’s real.”

Hill and Wilder acknowledged that while they are “pretty sure” they have identified Brittani, they cannot say with 100 percent certainty. So, Hill left the option open for Rodgers to correct them.

“If people have information that contradicts what we’re saying, please let us know,” she said. “Or, Aaron, if you want to correct the record, let us know. But, pretty sure we found your wife.”

The pair ended the segment with a message for Brittani.

“Brittani, if you’re listening, truly, open invitation, come on the pod,” Hill said.