Who Is Craig Conover’s New Fling? 5 Things to Know About Natalie Buffett — And Her Famous Exes

Southern Charm star Craig Conover made headlines for saying that he’s dating someone new following his split from Paige DeSorbo — and Us Weekly confirmed he’s seeing Natalie Buffett.

“I’m very happy,” Conover shared during a March 2025 appearance on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen, teasing his new romance. (It’s been reported that Buffett was spotted in the crowd at the show’s taping.)

“When I date, I tend to date only one person at a time,” he continued. “I’ve been seeing someone. I’ve been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways, and everything happens for a reason.”

Conover’s latest fling comes after a three-year relationship with Summer House star DeSorbo. She announced during a December 2024 episode of her “Giggly Squad” podcast that they had split.

Keep scrolling for everything to know about Buffett:

1. Buffett Has an NFL Ex

Buffett may look familiar to some as she is the ex-girlfriend of Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott. The former couple went public in July 2020 and adopted two dogs together throughout their relationship. Buffett even appeared on the NFL Honors red carpet with Prescott in 2022, but news of their breakup was widely reported in 2023.

2. She Reportedly Has an MLB Ex Too

Buffett was romantically linked to MLB pitcher Jack Flaherty following her split from Prescott. She posted a photo kissing the athlete on Instagram in December 2023, but the image has since been deleted. It’s been widely reported that they split last year.

3. She Went to School in the South

Multiple outlets previously reported that Buffett graduated from Southern Methodist University in 2019, according to her since-deleted LinkedIn profile. In May 2021, she was named the director of content creation and strategy for OxeFit, a home gym company.

She is reportedly a Texas native and, according to the flags in her Instagram bio, has roots in Sweden and Canada.

4. Buffet Is an Influencer

It’s unclear if she still works for OxtFit, but Buffett has racked up more than 91,000 followers on Instagram, making her a certified social media influencer. Her comments on Instagram have since been set to limited.

5. She Is Not Related to Jimmy Buffett

In March 2025, a TikTok user debunked a rumor that Buffett was related to legendary singer Jimmy Buffett.