Tori Spelling Claims Her Dog Chewed on a ‘Severed Human Big Toe’ While Staying at a Toronto Hotel

Tori Spelling is looking back on her “creepiest hotel story.”

On the latest episode of her MisSpelling podcast, the Beverly Hills, 90210 alum, 52, recalled her shock after discovering her dog Musso was chewing on human remains while staying with her and her ex Dean McDermott at an unnamed hotel in Toronto.

“One time when Dean and I were together, we were in Toronto, and we were filming…[and] we had two days off,” she said. “So we’re like, ‘Oh, let’s go stay at this amazing Victorian hotel or something.’ So we went and stayed at this hotel, and I think it was me and Dean and my dog.” 

“And it was like the most prestigious hotel in Toronto and old school and beautiful. And we were like, okay, we’ve been working hard…[so] we ordered room service and we were gonna watch a movie,” she added. “And I’m not even sure how we found it, but we found a toe. Plot twist. Didn’t see that one coming, did you?”

The actress then recalled how she and McDermott realized that Musso had gotten a hold of the toe.

“Musso found something, and we were laying in bed watching a movie, and we just finished dinner and we found something, and he was chewing on something at the end of the bed,” she said. “And we’re like what does he have? And we kinda went back and forth, like, did he get our food? Like, did he find a bone here? Like, what is he chewing on?”

Spelling recalled that she “grabbed it out of his mouth, and that’s when I found it was a severed human big toe and the creepy part is it wasn’t that old.” 

She described the toe as not “that decayed” and “precisely chopped off.” She later added, “And if I remember correctly, it was definitely, I think, a male big toe, but it was chopped off, and it wasn’t decaying. And the nail bed was fine.”

However, the hotel did not seem overly concerned about the shocking discovery, according to Spelling.

“The hotel kind of had no reaction,” she claimed. “They were like, ‘Oh, we’re so sorry.’ So we, like, put it in a napkin from our dinner and Dean brought it down to them. But you guys, we never got — I would have been horrified, I would have been like, ‘I’m so sorry, the whole stay is free’ or I don’t even know how you make up for having a human toe in somebody’s bed.” 

“But all I know is I think they gave us a credit if we ever stayed there again. Ever stayed there again? Never going to stay there again,” she emphasized.

However, the pair were good sports about the harrowing experience. When a producer asked if she demanded to change rooms, she admitted, “No. We didn’t move rooms. I can’t even remember why we stayed in that room. I think it was late and we were just so tired from working.”

“We’re like, turn a blind toe to it and just move on,” she joked.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

In retrospect, Spelling has one regret, revealing that she should have put the toe “in a Ziploc bag.” 

“Oh my god, I’ve always wanted to solve a murder. I’ve always been into crime and stuff. That could have been my one chance to put in a Ziploc bag to go to the police station, and I could have solved a murder,” she said. “Oh, I missed out.”